New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday allows reservations 27% for other classrooms (OBC) and 10% for the economically weaker category (EWS) in the All-India Quota (AIQ) chair to enter all the medical chairs of the criteria There is this year.
Yesterday, after making a day-to-day hearing about the petition that challenged the Validity of the EWS quota in postgraduate medical acceptance and central arguments that supported the quota, the court on Thursday said there was a situation, where national interests, counseling must begin, which is also the main demand for protesting Resident doctor.
The bench consisting of Judge D.Y.
Chandrachud and A.S.
Bopanna said: “We are in a situation, where in national interests, counseling must begin.”
Safe! You have managed to throw your voteogin to see the results
Lawyer General Tushar Mehta, representing the center, argues that all candidates are quoted for EWS quota, according to existing criteria, has received their certificate for registration and adds that seats in all government universities have increased to accommodate EWS quota.
“So, this will not endanger the opportunity for the general category students …”, he added.
Mehta also clarified that special special courses did not have reservations and no judgment remotely showed that there could no reservations in the PG course.
In the aspect of the EWS quota, he said there was research, the application of mind, and extensive consultation when the government decided to improve the RS 8 Lakh income limit.
He handed over: “We are not in practice to find out who is poor.
The constitution uses a more economically weaker section …
whether more weaker students can economically compete with other students, get consideration.”
He clarified that income in this case was family income and if there were 3 members in the family to get Rs 3 Lakh per year, their income would be Rs 9 lakh and they would not come under the EWS category.
Senior Advocate Arvind Flat, representing several applicants, argues that no exact research is carried out to reach the income limit of Rs 8 Lakh and cite revenue differences in various countries.
He said that applying a uniform RS 8 rules throughout the country was arbitrary, and this quota must be suspended next year, instead of applying this year.
Advocates Archana Pathak Dave, appears for the Federation of Indian Doctors, said: “That every year it is estimated that 45,000 candidates are appointed as a postgraduate doctor through a neet-pg examination -19 and consequently delays in detention of neet-pg examination.
”
In application intervention, the doctor’s federation urges the upper court to enable the commencement of counseling.
Senior Advocate Shyam Divan, representing several doctors who took the exam, argued that postgraduate receipts must be fully based and ordered must be minimal and referred to the assessment of the Supreme Court which stated that there should be no reservation in a super-special course.
This center has received a three-member panel report formed to review the EWS criteria.
The panel, in his report, said: “First, the EWS criteria relating to the financial year before the application year while the income criteria for the cream layer in the OBC category apply to gross annual income for three consecutive years.”
The panel is added: “Second, if you determine the OBC cream layer, the income from salary, agriculture, and traditional artisanal profession is issued from consideration while the 8 lakh RS criteria for EWS include that of all sources, including agriculture.
So, even though it has a cut-off number same, the composition is different and therefore, both cannot be equated.
”
After hearing the parties in this matter, the top court has judged a challenging petition of 27 percent reservations for other backwards (OBC) and 10 percent reservation for EWS in the entire Indian medical chair for postgraduate medical courses.
A total of 15 percent of seats in MBBS and 50 percent of seats in the MS and MD courses are filled through the quota throughout India from the candidates chosen through NEET.